• Blog
  • About Me
    • Press Release
  • Back Road Wineries
    • California Wine Trail
    • Tuscany Wine Trail
    • Baja California Wine Trail
  • Wine A Bit ~ Editorial & Reviews
  • Contact Me

UNCORKED WINE TRAVELS

Musings Along The Wine Trails

Do Wine Credentials Really Add Value?

April 17, 2017 by Deborah Mines Leave a Comment

As Louis Pasteur reportedly said, “Chance favors the prepared mind”.  This may be true, however, Wine Spectator‘s Matt Kramer believes otherwise.  In a much contested Wine Spectator editorial, “Not A Trivial Pursuit,”  dated February 16, 2016, Kramer rants:

“The modern demand for a credential is larger and more substantive than mere careerism… We now insist on a kind of professionalization that has less to do with the benefits of an education and more to do with jumping through hoops held by others in order to acquire a diploma of some kind.”

At the time, when I read his column, I, too, was miffed, as were countless Sommeliers, Wine Educators and those pursuing professional wine education certificates and diplomas, dissing Kramer on social media.   I had personally just tested for the WSET Level 3 (Wine Spirit Education Trust) certification after four months of intensive study and  substantial cost.  Was I wasting my time?

Another month passed before I received my results from London’s WSET office that I had passed the exam with Merit.  Now I could finally add a set of initials post nominal to lend credibility to my future wine career.

I let Kramer’s remarks fade away until I sat for my FWS (French Wine Society) certification a few months later.   Once again, Kramer’s ignorant editorial surfaced in my mind and I questioned the worth of obtaining another wine certification.  Alas, I had passed the FWS exam with Highest Honors and added another set of initials post nominal.

Proud of my two wine certification achievements, I thought, why not one go for one more certificate?  To help me on my way, I applied for and received two scholarships to offset the cost of attending the Napa Valley Wine Academy’s crash course for the CSW (Certified Specialist of Wine).  After several months of countless hours of studying, I passed the CSW exam with flying colors and added yet, another set of initials post nominal.

Despite Kramer’s dim view of flaunting one’s wine milestone accomplishments, I am proud to be certifiably certified.

Deborah Mines, WSET Level 3, FWS, CSW

Filed Under: California Wine Trail, Wine A Bit Tagged With: CSW, FWS, wine certifications, Wine Spectator, WSET

Wine Trail Search

Follow My Wine Blog

    Your Name

    Your Email

    A Little About Me

    To many, I’m simply known as a wanderlust ~ a free-spirited adventuress with a passion for travel and a lover of great wines!Read more...

    Vintage Posts

    • Ojai’s Spiritual Vortex (And Great Wine) Soothes The Soul April 4, 2021
    • Book Review: The Billionaire’s Vinegar January 3, 2021
    • Book Review: Sonoma Wine And The Story Of Buena Vista November 29, 2020
    • California Wineries Are Now “Waiting For The Other Shoe To Drop…” November 15, 2020
    • Russian River Valley Welcomes Visitors in Uncertain Times… September 20, 2020
    • BOOK REVIEW: A Wine Journey Along The Russian River May 30, 2020
    • US Wine Market Update: A Regional Perspective Webinar Unites Top Industry Leaders April 17, 2020
    • The Lifecycle of a Grape Vine ~ From Vine To Wine March 26, 2020
    • 2019’s “Top 10” Eclectic RRV Wineries December 29, 2019
    • Russian River Valley’s Arista Wines Earn Top Accolades From Wine Spectator September 24, 2019
    • Littorai Wines ~ A Tale of Two Coasts & Three Pinot Noir Styles September 13, 2019
    • After Much Ado, “House of Flowers” Debuts In Russian River Valley August 29, 2019
    • Best Backroads For Cycling In RRV-Healdsburg Wine Country August 16, 2019
    • Experience Cave-Aged Wines At DRNK Winery in Russian River Valley July 3, 2019
    • Best Kept Secret in Sta. Rita Hills ~ Spear Vineyards & Winery May 17, 2019
    • Spring Is An Ideal, And Uncrowded, Time To Visit Wine Country April 19, 2019
    • NEW BOOK RELEASE: Root Cause, A Novel by Steven Laine February 19, 2019
    • Discover the Hidden Wine Caves in Sonoma Wine Country December 17, 2018
    • Vin Santo Reigns In Chianti’s Medieval Hamlet of Castello di Volpaia November 16, 2018
    • Hidden Gem Alert ~ Dry Creek’s Unti Vineyards Is A “10” October 31, 2018

    Copyright © 2021 · Lifestyle Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in